• 0 Posts
  • 120 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: March 26th, 2024

help-circle




  • This is a no true scottsman on critical thinking.

    I’m going to copy my reply to Barney above.

    We have all sorts of evidence for conflicting conclusions. Most of us do not have the time or resources get a lock on which evidence is truly trustworthy.

    If you talk to a flat earther, or a dedicated follower of the oppossing political team, you will see they understand faulty sources, chains of logic, and deductive reasoning, they just only apply them in support of their position.

    You can teach a person about bias in research or media and they will use that knowledge to discredit positions they don’t agree with.

    You can say “that’s not critical thinking” and on one hand I agree, but teaching more thourough critical thinking skills won’t have the result we want: for people to make evidence based decisions about their life and society.

    In my experience, Getting people to change their minds requires engaging their emotions. Decisions are made on the basis or shame, fear, anger, and more rarely, love, hope, and empathy.

    The evidence needs to be there to support the emotion, but nobody ever changes their behavior on the strength of the evidence alone.


  • We have all sorts of evidence for conflicting conclusions. Most of us do not have the time or resources get a lock on which evidence is truly trustworthy.

    If you talk to a flat earther, or a dedicated follower of the oppossing political team, you will see they understand faulty sources, chains of logic, and deductive reasoning, they just only apply them in support of their position.

    You can teach a person about bias in research or media and they will use that knowledge to discredit positions they don’t agree with.

    You can say “that’s not critical thinking” and on one hand I agree, but teaching more thourough critical thinking skills won’t have the result we want: for people to make evidence based decisions about their life and society.

    In my experience, Getting people to change their minds requires engaging their emotions. Decisions are made on the basis or shame, fear, anger, and more rarely, love, hope, and empathy.

    The evidence needs to be there to support the emotion, but nobody ever changes their behavior on the strength of the evidence alone.







  • Not in stem but the same thing happened to me. I used to be able to speak to a room and be heard. Now I need to raise my voice, sound a little whiney or bitchy or nobody hears me. Only my closest friend still asks me for advice or to share my knowledge. Used to happen all the time.

    At least I pass. I got that going for me.



  • Ok, so, telling lenders they cannot vet lenders is not reasonable.

    Our critiques of credit scores does not automatically mean we want them abolished in favor the previous wink and a handshake.

    But American credit scores don’t measure your likelihood to pay back debts, they measure the likelihood of a lender to make money off of you. Those are nearly, but not quite, the same thing, and our current system, as the previous poster said, leads to a lifetime of debt obligations.

    What we want is for life to not be dependant on debt.



  • Bernie might have helped but even if he got into office Congress would have stopped nearly everything he campaigned on.

    The administrative state would not have been torn up but that’s just tinkering around the edges. Things like IRS free file expansion or banking at the post office.

    The supreme Court would belong to Democrats but…tinkering around the edges.

    If Bernie got re-elected (no guarantee, his first term would have ended in COVID and broken promises, probably impeachment by a Republican house). 2024 would 100% have gone to a Republican.

    We don’t need Bernie now. His plans are mostly just a harder crank on the ratchet. Good, but insufficient. We need Allende. Someone that wants to build non-mariet solutions to make our lives better, and a movement behind them in Congress.