• diffcalculus@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    2
    ·
    10 months ago

    I’m no law expert, but I have dealt with POS and retailers, and their tax people. My understanding is that you always report the loading of a gift card as a liability. It may be categorized as a different liability because you don’t necessarily owe that money back. As in, most gift cards are non refundable.

    When the holder of the gift card redeems it for products, the balanced used gets deducted from your liability and is added to revenue.

    If Starbucks were straight reporting it as revenue with no explanation, I can see that being scrutinized. But if they are reporting it as potential revenue, then that’s up to shareholders to weed through that and make investments based on that.

    I’m not understanding the illegality here.