You know how XKCD sometimes draws fantasy maps of like, the internet or something? I’m picturing a map like that of internet marketplaces, and there’s a dark amorphous cloud whose nature I’m not entirely sure of that strongly compels sellers to need 5-star reviews like a smack addict.
In a healthy, honestly run marketplace, 5.0 ratings will functionally never happen. Because idiots exist. For example, I bought a small inverter that runs off of drill batteries. It’s powered from a 20v lithium ion battery pack meant to run power tools, it has a standard American Type B power socket on it to power things that run on AC, but it’s limited to 150 watts. The reviews were divided into two camps: 4 and 5 star reviews from those who understood that last sentence, and 1 and 2 star reviews from those who don’t.
I really don’t want to buy a product that has a few 5 star reviews, because that almost certainly means it’s dropshipped Chinese garbage, the reviews are either fake or coerced.











There was some kerfluffle in the gaming press like this; a lot of magazines used to score games out of 10, with a 7/10 being effectively the lowest possible score. “When I booted the game up, my C64 caught fire, as did my Spectrum, which was turned off at the time and not relevant to this review. Then the developer kicked in the door, gave everyone in the building AIDS, then went on a worldwide tour kicking every single puppy. 7/10.”
There was a magazine that was in the habit of actually using the entire scale with a “meh, s’alright” being a 5/10, and some developers outright blacklisted them for it.
It’s like how grades of meat are all positive sounding. Which is the worst grade of meat: Prime, Select or Choice?
I once saw a documentary with the engineer who worked on the toilet equipment such as it was on the Apollo spacecraft. Urine was collected essentially by a condom with a hose at the end, which came in three sizes. Of course none of the astronauts would be caught dead ordering anything but a large so they were labeled “large, gigantic and humongous.”