overweight is a weird group to use because it doesn’t really apply to people

Overweight people aren’t people?

Sounds like the players here had a good time.

That’s your read on the story?

Making a lot of assumptions and claims about a literal fantasy creature.

The specific details aren’t important, but yeah. A lot less HP than can survive 10d10 damage.

They’re introducing the BBEG to a level 1 party, so that barbarian probably only has around 10 hp

I play using a VTT so everybody sees what the results are immediately. No telling it to them gently when the troll crits three times during the fight.

Dudes wearing Oakley’s and Fox Racing hats would be saying they’re better than you because you don’t work 22 hour days.